The Red Badge of Courage

The Red Badge of Courage is now universally recognized as a masterpiece, although when it first appeared
in book form in 1896 (two months later in England than in the United States) it provoked mixed reactions.
The English critics, in fact, brought it to the attention of the American public, which had generally ignored
it. Those early readers who approved saw in it a "true and complete picture of war," a book which "thrusts
aside romantic machinery" in favor of dramatic action and photographic revelation. Its critics attacked it for
what they considered its utter lack of literary form - its "absurd similes," "bad grammar," and "violent
straining after effect." Edward Garnett, however, praised its "perfect mastery of form," and Conrad, who
had known Crane, said in 1926 that The Red Badge of Courage was a "spontaneous piece of work which
seems to spurt and flow like a tapped stream from the depths of the writer's being," and he found it "virile
and full of gentle sympathy!
" while it was happily marred by no "declamatory sentiments." Throughout the first four decades of the
century the book was variously praised and condemned for its naturalism or "animalism," its realism and its
extraordinary style. V. S. Pritchett, writing in 1946, may be said to represent the prevailing opinion when
he declares that Crane's "verisimilitude," his grasp of "human feelings," and his "dramatic scenes and
portraits" give The Red Badge of Courage a place in the literature of war.

It is only in the forties that serious literary analysis of the book begins. It had of course long been
recognized that novels such as Zola's La Debacle and Tolstoy's Sevastopol and War and Peace had had
some influence on Crane, and that he had made use of Battles and Leaders of the Civil War (which had first
appeared serially in the Century Magazine) as well as accounts of particular campaigns; his brother
William, for one thing, was an expert on the strategy of the Battle of Chancellorsville, and there are many
parallels with this battle to be found in The Red Badge. But scholars like Pratt, Webster, Osborn, and
Stallman began to call attention to the possible role played by less significant factors, like Crane's personal
acquaintance with General Van Petten, an instructor at Claverack College, who might have provided him
with a first-hand account of the Battle of Antietam. Crane may also have derived some less important
conceptions from Civil War potboilers like Hinman's C!
orporal Si Klegg or Kirkland's The Captain of Company K. Although Crane himself acknowledged an early
influence by Kipling's novels, it was S. C. Osborn who pointed out that the famous "red wafer" image at the
close of Chapter 9 probably had its source in Kipling's The Light That Failed, and who thereby inaugurated
a discussion (maintained chiefly by R. W. Stallman) about the meaning of this image. The "wafer" may be
a wax sealing wafer or it may be, as Stallman suggests, an allusion to the Christian communion wafer, but
it lies at the center of the controversy concerning the alleged Christian symbolism of the novel.

Discussions of the structure and total meaning of the novel date from about 1950. John Schroeder
believes that Crane has not achieved a successful accommodation of antithetical elements: "War as man-
made blasphemy" is not "distinguishable from nature's pattern of serene wisdom"; and he feels that the
"putting off of the Old Man [by the youth] . . . is largely a matter of accident." R. W. Stallman, on the other
hand, asserts that a consistent, meaningful pattern unifies the story. The Red Badge "is about the self -
combat of a youth who fears and stubbornly resists change and spiritual growth. . . . Henry's regeneration is
brought about by the death of Jim Conklin." Psychological and mythic criticism of a book whose action
centers mainly about a "wound" was perhaps inevitable, and Maxwell Geismar (1953) explains that
"Fleming's shame at his psychic wound . . . led him to yearn for the physical wound." The basic pattern of
the narrative conforms to that of "acceptance after a t!
rial by ordeal." Geismar further sees this as all a reflection of Crane's own "psychic wound," declaring that
"much of Crane's career was spent in the attempt to validate the imaginary experience in The Red Badge